@Schezo: I disagree that my question would have caused people to attack others over nothing. At the very least, the attacks would be on the levels of typical ED1 cases. It's not like every single post aside from Bard's gambit was completely perfect.
I think it was pretty obvious why UK looked like the best of the three Bard voters at that point. PX was derping around and Dormio was attacking UK while keeping his vote on the largest wagon.
I never told anybody to ignore Bard's gambit completely or leave it out of discussion, and it irritates me that people keep implying I did so. I never waffled on Bard, either - his actual gambit and his choice to end the RVS are different things in my mind.
What about Bard's posting and opinions is townie to you?
They seem logical to me and read fluently. It's obvious not a perfect town read, considering that it's D1 of all things. I just think he's more townie than not.
@HW 59: Just want a clarification. Do you think Dormio attacking me but voting Bard has any relation to my alignment? This isn't very clear.
It suppose it could, but that was not what was going through my head when I wrote the post. I was mainly seeing it as "Dormio is attacking other people while staying on the wagon that currently has the largest chance of going through".
@Huh What: Please explain how people were "nitpicking".
"People"? The only person voting me at that time was Shadoweh. You act as if I was a major target or something.
Regardless, as far as I can tell, Shadoweh's case consisted of:
- huh what attacked the people reacting to Bard's stunt despise not giving a full-on reaction himself
- huh what accused people of coasting when nothing else had happened yet (not true)
- Apparently something that she needed to know my opinions on Bard to solve?
Only one of these things is scummy, and it is also a misrep. The first point looked more like Gotcha Games to me than a legitimate point, since I should not have needed to react to Bard myself to pass judgment on those who did. Her question about my opinions on Bard still baffles me, since as far as I can tell they did not actually affect her case, and it seemed like she was trying to find something else to hang me on with that question. I do not know how not having entirely clear opinions on Bard would be scummy, since there was still evidence towards my actual take on the matter and he was clearly not a major target of mine at that point regardless. It's not like I had no clear opinions at all.
I still prefer a Dormio lynch above all else. A majority of his game has been spent tunneling on UK over weak points and invalid conspiracy theories and yet refusing to let go. He seems to be focusing on her way too much, which seems odd considering how weak his jabs at her are. I've been weary of people who come across as making shotgun attacks by being nitpicky rather than actually posting solid cases this game in general, and Dormio has possibly been the most notable example of this so far. If one ISOs his posts, it becomes pretty evident that while he has a large amount of points against UK, none of them are particularly overwhelming or convincing. UK has already defended herself pretty thoroughly so I don't intend to go through and attack Dormio's points, but as far as I can tell they pretty much speak for themself. It seems to me like Dormio is scum who made a weak earlygame case and is clinging to it while failing to provide substantial content regarding other players.
I dislike Shadoweh and PX too, as their initial votes were weak even for ED1 cases, and their later voteswitches come completely out of nowhere and seem rather out of place. It looks a lot like they just gave up on their past cases without actually explaining that they were backing down. As far as I am concerned, they are pretty much in the same boat right now. PX looks worse to me on paper since his Lambdadelta case makes just as little sense to me as the one on UK, but my gut tells me that Shadoweh is scummier because her switch to Dormio is seriously reminding me of when she backed off onto Sect during ED1 of Balanced Game of Mafia. I would be willing to switch to either, though, and I am not sure why so many people are giving Shadoweh free passes (really, guys, it's not like scum!Shadoweh couldn't have possibly been nervous about a town!Bard shooting her).
Why are people suddenly calling Hourai town again?
Cut by Kiro and Dormio. I guess if I wasn't a notable wagon earlier in the day I am now, sigh. I'll respond to Kiro later, was about to go do other things.
