OK, so, first thing that sticks out is
Dormio's vote on Bard. What was your opinion of the vig shot at the time? You clearly were able to react to it. But instead of even acknowledging it, you just choo choo with some RVS reasoning. I do not like this.
Second thing is Bard pressing me on why he's scum. I'm actually not sure about the intent here. If I had given a more decisive answer to start with, his continued pressing would be bad but, as it stands, I
think it's null, possibly slight scum, because I *did* explain why I "thought he was scum", and he chose to ignore it.
This is Dormio continusing to not provide much of a town/scum opinion on the dayvig. Which is actually really weird in retrospect. (Also no comment on my totes awesome "case" on Bard)
OH!
Shadoweh, you're still alive. I asked about this at the time. How I was supposedly "waffly". Please answer that now that your demise isn't a thing that's going to happen.
OK, this is all kinds of weird from Bard. Dormio and PX are scummiest, but you'd lynch Dormio first and UK second. Further, my wafflyness never IS explained. Please to be doing that. Even with your ~*~derp~*~ caveat on PX, this post looks extremely awkward, particularly given the "Well should could be town because *meta*" part.
And then PX is being awful about not taking it seriously. Though I'll grant I misread that at the time as "I'm not going to take [the entire pregame phase] seriously". Suppose it had been a serious shot, PX. How would you have reacted to Bard? To people voting Bard? OH WAIT, I JUST ASKED SOMETHING LIKE THAT BECAUSE YOU WERE CHOO CHOO TUNNELING ON ME.
So, let me get this in a row here, Dormio. How does Bard's anti town dayvig make him scum? I couldn't ask well back then because of my own "stance" on the subject. But I'm serious now. Also, why would you rolefish Bard's ass for no reason?
@HW 59: Just want a clarification. Do you think Dormio attacking me but voting Bard has any relation to my alignment? This isn't very clear.
@Dormio 60: [[citation needed]]. WHY Wouldn't he be a town vig?
Dormio 66: [[citation needed]]. You continually explain how it's a "playing it safe"
Zak 69 is still hilarious, particularly given the ~*~new facts~*~.
Anyway, after all that what I'm getting by page four is that Dormio thinks I'm scum because I thought Shadoweh was town. He also uses a lot of rhetoric and vague statements to push this. I'm honestly kind of seeing where HW gets Dormio scum here.
PX 115: This is just awful but it's town awful. You think I misrepped Bard in relation to you, when it was an honest mistake. Further, I'd state that if I tried to implicate Bard because of things he said about you, I'd probably be pretty quickly caught by, yanno, people READING THE POST IN QUESTION. Your other point is a gotcha game that misreps ME. No, I just couldn't reasonably push a case on scum Bard vigging scum Shadoweh (FOR GOOD REASON IT TURNS OUT BECAUSE I TOTALLY FORGOT THE N2 RECRUIT).
Actually, I do have one issue with it. It sort of reads a bit like "Huh, I need to call someone scum. Oh, someone is voting UK.
I should vote UK. This is the best motherfucking idea I ever had. Oh...but how will I make her scum? Hmm...well, if I assume she's scum, posts X, Y, and Z look scummy. AM I DOIN IT RITE?" Let me be charitable and just say no. No you are not, PX.
Hmm, I'd like Dorian to post again, more fully about the other players. More importantly who he thinks is scum. His first post is mostly a waffle and it doesn't make me happy.
LLD: Now that I've remembered that a clear would only last until D3, had the shot been real, would you still advocate Bard scum if Shadoweh scum? What if Shadoweh had flipped town? Further, do Bard and Shadoweh still need to die with the fake shot? I also want my earlier questions answered, but you'll get to those.
Shadoweh 142: I hope things make more sense NOW. Course, had you actually flipped I'd still be pissed at Bard, even if I didn't think he was scum. Hmm, did HW fail to react to the vig? I thought he DID react with his gambit comment (which wasn't the best but not the worst). I kind of feel like he's been coming from a pro town place, trying to create information on intent as much as possible.
Shadoweh 168: I think the vig would have been mostly a null tell, had it been real. I'd probably have considered it slightly scummy, but not 100% lynch Bard now scummy.
Bard 169: What has changed between LLD's initial post and now that is causing you to vote her? She hasn't posted any reaction yet.
(Also, a bonus for PX!
More hinting I was reaction fishing)
tl;dr forthcoming.
