Thoughtdump. Skipping over Bard/Prims walls on this pass since they are huge and need a post of their own.
Dan vote on Raikaria in RVS. Scum often vote for other scums in RVS.
Dorian fence sitting on Dan, "against policy by default, even if this case seems good".
Dorian questioning Prims 'cop' result on Dan.
This little exchange:
(Prims picks on Dorian for being wishy washy and then)
'LLD, post a case so I can decide if you're town playing mafiascum and not Mafia or if I'm lynching you today.'
LLD responds with:
'You want a case? You're scum. There you go, case compiled.'
Dan interrupts with:"I'd actually be inclined to go with LLD over not going with LLD on this one.
But Raikaria is scum I bet."
Lexi responds with;
"This player has not posted anything since Day 1 begun. Why do you say this?"
Dan responds with;
"I'm using that confirm post."
Raikaria's
confirm post. However, he didn't vote.
*** thus making Dan the first player to pick scum from a confirm post. Did he guess, or know? ***
Schezo votes Raikaria fairly early in day 1, but notably outside of RVS. Probably townclear from this.
BT picking on CF7. BT and CF7 had several interactions, certainly more in number and more compelling than anything CF7 and I had. I'll refer back to this point if/when I get to Raikaria/Moridin/Dorian's relevant posts, later. It's important because IIRC those three made the same argument that is based on a faulty perspective of the game state, and I find it hard to believe three players could screw up in the same way at the same time unless they were working together. And, we know one of them was scum.
Raikaria post.Main points:
Defends Dorian as 'not rolefishing' (arguably he was not role fishing) and my case is speculative (of course it's speculative, because I don't KNOW, it's just an educated guess.) Discredits my case on Dorian, " I mean, asking if a vote is serious at this state and fence-sitting on a silly RVS policy lynch? That's not really anything you can read into."
Also mentions Bard in passing. Doesn't comment on Dan state himself.
Raikaria omgus on Schezo. Schezo basically towncleared imo.
Dorian vote for super pro town guy who should have been protected last night, but flipped green.
Moridin
claims (and has now established) ability to talk at night.
Raikaira again picks out Sky to discredit him (less so this time).
BT case and vote for Bard. Relevant for nightkill analysis? If so, though, Prims should have been nightkilled instead of BT.
Affinity's random flavor post that I assume is going to later be some kind of crumb, but the main guts is 'get off Dorian'.
Raikaria 'mulling over CF7/Sky interactions'. The BT/CF7 interactions are far more compelling so I have to wonder what is Raikaria's angle here.
Schezo questioning Moridin on his ability. The wording seems to me that Schezo is surprised that Moridin is 'the only one' with this ability. Seeing as I think Schezo is super town I don't want him to claim but if you have any...I don't know, inside info, let us know with a vote.
*observes Schezo voting Moridin day 2* Hmmmmmmmmmmm
Dorian getting in another vote on a player I think is definitely green.
Handwave Skycase. No real content in this post.
Challenges Schezo over his Raikaria vote. So a big black mark on Dorian here.
Dorian handwave dismiss of wagon on Bard.
Raikaria post.Main points:
Rolefishing - asks for Moridin claim.
Says Prims is not making sense.
Argues against Schezo by citing timezones.
Fencesits over Sky and CF7 and finally votes Lexi for attitude and afk -
why not vote Dan for afk, that wagon was further ahead than Lexi.
This gem:
"I don't like anyone who used 'Fence Sitting' as an actual case. Because it's stupid and smells of just making up any reason to lynch people. I'm looking at Sky_Paladin and Bard here. People using confirmation posts as reasons people are scum is also bad especially when they do not explain how that post is scummy [Actiondan and Sky]"
That's two attempts to discredit me on my Dorian vote in one paragraph lol.
Prims critics Raikaria for his LLD vote instead of Dan. Unlikely to come from a scumbuddy. Prims actually put a lot of shots against Raikaria in the next few posts.
Schezo votes for Dan without a stated reason although there is no wagon on Rai at this point, so he didn't change his vote to save Raikaria.
Prims slam dunk on Raikaria. Not the kind of thing scumbuddies do. Almost certainly town. Schezo will now immediately revote Raikaria.
CF7 reluctant to lynch Raikaria.
Raikaria post. Main points:
Hates Sky, like in every post. Man I wish that was enough to be a townclear but, you know, wifom etc. Also hates CF7 despite CF7 saying he doesn't want to lynch him. Leaning town on CF7 now.
***
end of page 6, halfway done.
***
BT going Umineko on Raikaria. Probably enough to indicate Sky is town but you know ^__~
BT presses Dorian (relevant because nightkill analysis).
Raikaria post.Main points:
Again attacks Sky for his vote on Dorian. That's, what, six or seven times now.
Attacks Schezo.
Dorian post. Main points:
Attacks Schezo for his vote on Raikaria.
Argues against Prims, asks for Schezo's head.
Attacks Sky because
Dorian mistook that Sky consolidated on to ActionDan, not Raikaria Scumslip - "So, can you tell me why you prefer a Raikaria lunch over the scums that you apparently ?caught red-handed??"
I am voting ActionDan. Anyway at this point Rai and Dorian have so many mutually exclusive defends I'd gambit a fake guilty on Dorian if I had the audacity.
Affinity calls out the ActionDan wagon, votes for Raikaria. Probably town clear here since Rai was behind on votes.
Raikaria post.Main points:
Calls for Sky's or Schezo's head, favors Sky.
***end of page 7***
I'm about out of time for tonight so I'll post my town/scum picks, leaving myself out naturally. The flipped scum spent all day 1 hating me so I hope I'm town by association by now. Anyway.
TOWN
Basically confirmed town tier:
6. Schezo
2. Affinity
4. Huhwhat
Not real sure tier:
12. CF7
10. Moridin84
Probably scum in here
5. Bardiche
7. ActionDan
11. Lexicat
Basically confirmed scum tier:
1. Dorian
SCUM
##vote DorianContinuing. I'm aware there's a new day and Moridin said some shaky stuff and people are voting Prims so my opinions may change, it's just it's nearly bed time and I want to get this wall done so I can move on.
